LMA5502 and LMA5503 Analysis

About LMA5502 and LMA5503

Drafted by the Lloyd’s Market Association (LMA) and released in May 2020, LMA5502 and LMA5503 are limited communicable disease exclusions for Property Treaty Reinsurance.

Clause 1: the exclusion

At its broadest, Clause 1 of LMA5502 and LMA5503 exclude damage and loss ‘in connection with’:

• a Communicable Disease; or
• the fear or threat (whether actual or perceived) of a Communicable Disease.

Because all that is required between the damage/loss and Communicable Disease is a ‘connection’, the Communicable Disease may not have to be a cause of the damage/loss for the exclusion to apply. This intended breadth of the exclusion is further demonstrated by the words ‘regardless of any other cause contributing concurrently or in any sequence thereto’ in clause 1.

Clause 2: exception to the exclusion

Clause 2 of LMA5502 provides an exception to the exclusion of clause 1 such that the reinsurance agreement will cover:

• physical damage to property insured; and,
• business interruption (‘Time Element Loss’)

that arise from the listed perils, i.e. fire, lightning, explosion, aircraft or vehicle impact, falling objects, windstorm, rainstorm, hail, tornado, cyclone, typhoon, hurricane, earthquake, seaquake, seismic and/or volcanic disturbance/eruption, tsunami, flood, freeze, ice storm, weight of snow or ice, avalanche, meteor/asteroid impact, landslip, landslide, mudslide, bush fire and forest fire.

LMA5503 preferable to LMA5502 for insureds

The exception for LMA5503, however, extends to the following additional perils: riot, riot attending a strike, civil commotion, vandalism and malicious mischief. As such, LMA5503 is preferred to LMA5502 from an insured’s perspective.

Clause 3: definition of ‘Communicable Disease’

In clause 3 of LMA5502 and LMA5503, ‘Communicable Disease’ is defined as ‘any disease which can be transmitted… from any organism to another organism’.  Requiring the disease to be transmissible between organisms does qualify the scope of the definition; food poisoning, for example, would not be excluded as a ‘Communicable Disease’ because it is transmitted by the ingestion of contaminated food or water, not by a pathogen that is transmitted between organisms.

Beyond this,

• sub-clause 3.1 inclusively identifies types of pathogens;
• sub-clause 3.2 inclusively identifies means of transmission; and,
• sub-clause 3.3 identifies possible effects of the disease or pathogen.

None of these sub-clauses, however, are essential to the operation of the endorsement.

Clause 4: definition of ‘Time Element Loss’

Finally, clause 4 of LMA5502 and LMA5503 define ‘Time Element Loss’ as business interruption, contingent business interruption or any other consequential losses.